Opening the lab

Refraction Through a Glass Block  / CSEC Physics
n = sin i / sin r
All labs
A top view of a sheet of paper with a rectangular glass block, an incident ray, the refracted ray inside the block, the parallel emergent ray, four pins and a protractor, beside a graph of sin i against sin r built from the recorded readings.
Ray in air
Ray in glass
Sideways shift
Your readings
Line of best fit
Theory

Set up the ray

Human errors
Readings carry realistic slips, like a real student's
Move the incident pinsabout 40°
Protractor (a 180° one, as in your set)
Graph
Zoom in on the protractor
Finer marks: read to 0.5° instead of 1°
Show the theory
Draws what Snell’s law predicts for this block
Try this: drag pin 1 (or use the slider) to set the incident ray. Put the protractor on the top face to read i, tap Measure r to turn it over into the glass and read r, then press Record. Take it off to see the bare diagram. Do it for six or more angles from about 10° to 80°, then look at sin i against sin r.
How to answer: put sin i on top: n = sin i ÷ sin r, with both angles measured from the normal.
Angle of incidence, i
–°
Angle of refraction, r
–°
sin i ÷ sin r, this reading
–
Mean of sin i ÷ sin r
–

Results table

Set the incident ray, read the protractor, then press Record i and r.
Record at least 3 readings first

Working

Light bends at a boundary

Light travels more slowly in glass than in air. When a ray meets a glass surface at an angle, one side of the beam slows down before the other, so the ray changes direction. This bending is called refraction.

  • The normal is the line at right angles to the surface at the point where the ray meets it.
  • The angle of incidence, i, is between the incident ray and the normal.
  • The angle of refraction, r, is between the refracted ray and the normal.
Common CSEC error: measuring i or r from the surface of the block. Both angles are measured from the normal.

The laws of refraction

  • The incident ray, the refracted ray and the normal all lie in one plane. On the paper, that is the flat sheet.
  • For a given pair of materials, sin i ÷ sin r is constant. This is Snell’s law.

Going from air into glass, the ray bends towards the normal, so r is smaller than i. Going from glass back into air, it bends away from the normal.

Refractive index

n = sin i / sin r

The constant is the refractive index, n, of the glass. It has no unit, because it is a ratio. Ordinary glass has n of about 1.5. This lab gives each block a hidden n between 1.45 and 1.60.

Worked example: sin i = 0.75 and sin r = 0.50 give n = 0.75 ÷ 0.50 = 1.5.

Extension, not needed for CSEC: n is also the speed of light in air divided by its speed in the glass, n = c / v. With c = 3.0 × 10⁸ m/s and n = 1.5, the speed in the glass is 2.0 × 10⁸ m/s.

Through the rectangular block

  • The ray bends towards the normal on the way in, and away from it on the way out. The two faces are parallel, so the angle inside the glass is the same at both faces.
  • So the emergent ray is parallel to the incident ray.
  • It is not in the same line. It is shifted sideways by the lateral displacement, shown as d on the stage. The shift is bigger for a thicker block and for a bigger angle of incidence.
  • At i = 0 the ray goes straight through with no bend and no shift.

Extension: for a block of thickness t, d = t sin(i − r) ÷ cos r.

The graph

  • sin i against sin r is a straight line through the origin. The gradient is n, with no unit.
  • i against r is a curve. The angles themselves are not proportional, only their sines are.

With a ray from air into glass there is always a refracted ray. Since sin r = sin i ÷ n, and sin i is at most 1, r can never be bigger than about 42° for n = 1.5. Total internal reflection can only happen the other way, from glass to air, above the critical angle. This experiment never reaches it.

Must the line pass through the origin?

Snell’s law says sin i = n sin r, so sin i is directly proportional to sin r. When sin r is zero, sin i is zero too: a ray that hits the block along the normal (i = 0°) is not bent (r = 0°).

So draw your line of best fit through (0, 0), with the points scattered either side of it. That scatter is human error in reading angles. If your line misses the origin, the most likely cause is a zero error on the protractor, which adds the same small angle to every reading, or a normal that is not drawn exactly at right angles to the face.

The method

  • Lay the block on a sheet of paper and draw round it.
  • Draw a normal at a point O on one face, and a line making the angle i you want. Stick two pins, P1 and P2, upright on this line, well apart.
  • Look through the block from the other side and place P3 and P4 so that all four pins look to be in one line.
  • Remove the block and pins. Draw a line through P3 and P4 to the far face, at E. Join O to E: that is the refracted ray.
  • Measure i and r with the protractor, and repeat for six or more values of i.

Precautions and sources of error

PrecautionWhy
Pins vertical (check with a set square)A leaning pin makes its base and its top point to different places.
Pins at least 6 cm apartA longer line through two pins gives a more accurate direction.
Sight along the bases of the pinsThe base is where the pin touches the paper.
Mark and label the pin positions clearlySo the right points are joined up afterwards.
  • The pins are not exactly in line with the path of the ray.
  • The protractor may have a zero error or a calibration error, and there is a measuring error in reading it.
  • It is hard to read the angle exactly between pencil lines that have some thickness.

Where Paper 3 asks it

His notes give no clear Paper 3 year for this experiment, so none is claimed here. It is a standard CSEC practical, and questions on it follow the usual pattern: complete a table of sin i and sin r, plot a graph, find the gradient, and give precautions and sources of error. The Paper 3 practice tab walks through each of those.

About this lab: it is a model. Snell’s law is exact here, and the scatter of about 1° in the protractor reading is a chosen value, not measured from a real protractor.