Opening the lab

Half-Life: the Dice Model  / CSEC Physics
N halves every half-life
All labs
A box of one hundred dice. Each throw removes the dice that show the decayed face, and a graph of the number of dice left against the number of throws builds up beside it.
This run
Earlier runs
Smooth curve
Theory

Set up the dice

Human errors
Readings carry realistic slips, like a real student's. The dice already make every run different
Sides on each die
Face that decays1 in 6
Speed
Show the smooth curve
A best-fit curve through your points
Mark the half-life on the graph
N falls to half, then half again. Needs the curve
Show what theory predicts
The average of very many runs
Try this: press Auto throw and watch the graph. Then Start again and compare: no two runs are the same, but each one halves in about the same number of throws. Last, try a die with more sides.
How to answer: each half-life halves the number left. A fixed fraction decays on each throw, not a fixed number.
Throws so far
0
Dice left, N
100
Removed last throw
–
Fraction left, N ÷ N0
1.00

Results table

Record at least 3 readings first

Working

Switch on Human errors in Explore to practise with readings like a real experiment.
Record at least 3 readings first

What half-life means

A radioactive sample is made of unstable nuclei. Each one can decay at any moment, and nobody can say which nucleus will go next or when. But the number of nuclei that have not yet decayed falls in a very regular way.

The half-life is the time taken for the number of undecayed nuclei (or the activity) to fall to half. It stays the same however many nuclei are left.

Common CSEC error: thinking a sample is all gone after two half-lives. After two half-lives a quarter is left, after three an eighth. The number halves each time, and never quite reaches zero.

The dice model

  • Each die stands for one unstable nucleus.
  • One throw stands for one equal interval of time.
  • A die showing the chosen face has decayed, so it is taken out. The others stay and are thrown again.
  • The number of dice left, N, plays the part of the number of undecayed nuclei.

This is a model. Real nuclei do not roll dice, but they decay with the same kind of chance, so the model behaves in the same way.

Why the graph is a curve

On every throw, the same fraction of the dice decays: 1 in 6 for a six-sided die. When there are many dice, many are removed. When there are few, only a few are removed. So the graph of N against the number of throws is a curve that falls steeply at first, then flattens.

N ≈ N0 × (5/6)t

With s sides, each throw leaves the fraction (1 − 1/s) of the dice. Halving takes ln 2 ÷ (−ln(1 − 1/s)) throws. For a six-sided die that is about 3.8 throws. Your run will not match this exactly, for the reason in the next card. The formula is an extension, not needed for CSEC.

Does this line pass through the origin?

No. This graph is a curve, not a straight line, and it does not start at the origin. At t = 0 no dice have decayed yet, so the curve starts at N0, the number of dice you began with, high up on the vertical axis.

The curve falls steeply, then flattens, so it is not a straight line from N0 down to zero. Draw a smooth curve through the points, and do not force it to start at (0, 0).

Random, but predictable

  • One run scatters about the smooth curve. Some throws remove a few more than expected, some a few fewer.
  • With more dice the scatter matters less, and the points follow the curve more closely.
  • With few dice the half-life from one run is a poor estimate. Use more dice, or repeat the run and average.
  • The half-life is the same for every run, because the chance of decay on each throw never changes.

Reading the half-life from the graph

  • Draw a smooth curve through the points. Do not join them dot to dot.
  • Find N0 ÷ 2 on the vertical axis. Go across to the curve, then straight down to the horizontal axis. That number of throws is the half-life.
  • Repeat from N0 ÷ 2 to N0 ÷ 4. It takes the same number of throws. That is the proof that the half-life is constant.

The half-life is a number of throws, so its unit is throws.

Different dice

SidesChance of decay per throwHalf-life (theory)
41 in 4about 2.4 throws
61 in 6about 3.8 throws
101 in 10about 6.6 throws
201 in 20about 13.5 throws

The smaller the chance of decay, the longer the half-life. Real isotopes run from a tiny fraction of a second to billions of years.

Precautions and sources of error

PrecautionWhy
All dice land inside the boxA die that leaves the box is lost from the count.
A big enough box, dice not piled upDice on top of one another are easy to miscount.
Count carefully after every throwOne slip carries on to every later throw.
Remove the same face every timeThe chance of decay must stay the same.
  • Dice that fall out of the box.
  • Dice that land on top of one another.
  • Dice piled in one corner, which makes them hard to count.
  • Random variation: a small sample gives a poor half-life.

Where Paper 3 asks it

His notes list the half-life dice experiment as set in May/June 2017, Paper 3, Question 2. Questions like it ask for the number of dice left after each throw, a graph of N against the number of throws, and the half-life read from the curve. The Paper 3 practice tab walks through each of those parts.