Opening the lab

Heating & Cooling Curves  / CSEC Physics
it melts at 0, not at 20
All labs
A block of ice in a beaker with a thermometer, beside a graph of temperature against energy supplied.
Warming the ice
Melting, temperature frozen at 0
Warming the water
Boiling at 100

Set up the experiment

Which way
It starts as
Mass of ice100 g
Ice starts at−20 °C
Heat it up to20 °C
Energy absorbed0 kJ
Watch the thermometer during a change of state. Energy is still flowing, the sample is visibly changing, and the temperature does not move at all.

It has to arrive first. Heating, the water must reach 100 before any of it turns to steam. Cooling, it must reach 0 before any of it freezes.

Flip between heating and cooling and watch the curve mirror. The energies are identical, only the direction changes.
Temperature
−20°C
Energy so far
0kJ
Ice left
100%
What is happening
Warming the ice

The calculation, stage by stage

The mistake this fixes

Asked for the energy to turn ice at −20 °C into water at 20 °C, most students write one line:

Q = mcΔT  with  ΔT = 40
That is wrong, and badly wrong. It ignores the melting entirely, which is the biggest part of the job. For 100 g the one step answer gives 16 800 J when the real answer is 46 200 J, nearly three times more.

Ice does not become 20 °C water in one go. It warms to 0, then melts at 0, then the water warms to 20. Three stages, three separate sums.

The two formulas

Which one you need depends on whether the temperature is changing.

Q = mcΔT

for a temperature change with no change of state. Here c is the specific heat capacity of whatever phase it is in at the time.

Q = mL

for a change of state at constant temperature. There is no ΔT in this one, because there is no temperature change.

The give-away: if the temperature is not changing, you cannot be using mcΔT, because ΔT would be zero and you would get nothing.

Why the temperature stops

While ice melts, the energy going in is used to break the bonds holding the molecules in their fixed lattice, not to speed them up.

Temperature measures the average kinetic energy of the molecules. During melting the energy is going into potential energy instead, so the thermometer does not move.

Only once every last bit of ice has melted does further energy start speeding the molecules up again, and the temperature climbs.

How much of the energy melting takes

StageEnergy for 100 gShare
Warm ice −20 to 04 200 J9%
Melt at 033 600 J73%
Warm water 0 to 208 400 J18%

Melting takes more energy than both warming stages put together, and produces no temperature rise whatsoever. That is why the flat section of the graph is the longest one.

The values to use

QuantityValue
c, ice2 100 J/kg/°C
c, water4 200 J/kg/°C
c, steam2 000 J/kg/°C
L, fusion (melting)3.36 × 105 J/kg
L, vaporisation (boiling)2.26 × 106 J/kg
Use the right c. Ice and water have different specific heat capacities, so the same 20 °C rise costs twice as much for water as for ice.

Boiling is even bigger

The latent heat of vaporisation is about 6.7 times the latent heat of fusion. Turning 100 g of water at 100 °C into steam at 100 °C takes 226 000 J, against 33 600 J to melt the same mass of ice.

That is because boiling has to pull the molecules completely apart, while melting only has to loosen them enough to slide past one another.

It is also why steam at 100 °C scalds far worse than water at 100 °C: it gives up all that latent heat as it condenses on your skin.

Reading the heating curve

  • Sloping sections: one phase, temperature rising, use mcΔT.
  • Flat sections: a change of state, temperature constant, use mL.
  • A steeper slope means a smaller specific heat capacity, since less energy is needed per degree.
  • A longer flat section means a bigger latent heat.

The ice section is steeper than the water section because c for ice is half that of water.

Cooling is the mirror image

Run it backwards and everything matches. Steam cools to 100, condenses at 100, the water cools to 0, freezes at 0, then the ice cools further.

  • The energy released when steam condenses is exactly the energy needed to boil it.
  • The energy released when water freezes equals the energy needed to melt the ice.
  • The plateaus sit at the same two temperatures, 0 and 100.
Same trap, other direction. Steam at 100 °C does not become ice in one step. It must reach each plateau and finish the change of state before the temperature moves again.

Why steam scalds so badly

100 g of steam at 100 °C landing on skin releases 226 000 J as it condenses, before it has even started to cool.

The same mass of water at 100 °C cooling to body temperature releases only about 26 000 J.

So steam delivers roughly nine times the energy, which is why a steam burn is far worse than a burn from boiling water at the same temperature. That is latent heat doing the damage.

Laying out your answer

Write each stage as its own line, with its own formula and its own numbers. Then add them.

  • Q₁ = mciceΔT = 0.1 × 2100 × 20 = 4 200 J
  • Q₂ = mLf = 0.1 × 336 000 = 33 600 J
  • Q₃ = mcwaterΔT = 0.1 × 4200 × 20 = 8 400 J
  • Total = 46 200 J
Marks are given per stage. Even if you slip on the arithmetic, a clearly laid out three stage answer earns most of them. One line earns almost none.