Opening the lab

Why the Split Ring?  / CSEC Physics
reverse the current at the dead spot
All labs
Two identical motor coils side by side, one without a commutator and one with, above a graph of turning effect against angle.
No commutator: turning effect reverses
Split ring: turning effect always forward
Current direction in each arm

Controls

Speed1.0×
Watch for this: both coils start identically and feel exactly the same force. The one on the left gets as far as the vertical, then the very same force starts pushing it back. It rocks, settles, and stops. The one on the right flips its current at that exact moment and keeps going.
No commutator
0.00
turns completed
With split ring
0.00
turns completed

What is happening

The turning effect changes as the coil turns

The two arms of the coil always feel equal and opposite forces, so together they make a couple that turns the coil. But the turning effect depends on the angle:

turning effect ∝ cos θ
  • Greatest when the coil lies along the field.
  • Zero when the coil is vertical. This is the dead spot.
  • Reversed beyond that, pushing the coil back the way it came.

Why a plain ring fails

With an ordinary continuous ring, the current in the coil never changes direction. So once the coil passes the vertical, each arm is on the opposite side of the field but still carrying current the same way.

By Fleming's Left Hand Rule the force on each arm is unchanged, but the arm has moved to the other side of the axle. The same force now produces a turning effect the other way round.

The coil swings back. It rocks about the dead spot and, with any friction at all, settles there and stops.

What the split ring does

The commutator is a ring cut into two halves, each connected to one end of the coil. The brushes press against it but stay still.

As the coil turns, the gap between the halves sweeps past the brushes. At that instant each half swaps to the other brush, which reverses the current through the coil.

The timing is everything. The gap reaches the brushes exactly as the coil passes the dead spot, which is precisely when the turning effect would otherwise reverse. Reversing the current at that moment cancels the reversal out.

Why the dead spot is the right moment

Switching there has two advantages, and both matter:

  • It is exactly where the turning effect would flip, so flipping the current instead keeps it forward.
  • The turning effect is zero there anyway, so nothing jolts. The switch happens at the quietest moment in the cycle.

Switch anywhere else and the motor would either lose drive or jerk violently.

The average turning effect

Over a full turn, the numbers make the point sharply.

Average turning effect
No commutatorZero. Forwards half the time, backwards the other half, cancelling exactly.
Split ringAbout 64% of peak. A steady forward push every moment of every turn.

A motor with no commutator has no net driving effect at all, no matter how strong the magnets or how large the current.

Real motors: more than one coil

Even with a split ring, a single coil still passes through the dead spot twice a turn, where the turning effect briefly drops to zero. Start it there and it will not move at all.

Real motors use several coils set at different angles, each with its own pair of commutator segments. They never all reach a dead spot together, so:

  • The motor is self starting from any position.
  • The turning effect is much smoother, with no dips.

Split ring against slip rings

Split ringSlip rings
ShapeOne ring cut in twoTwo separate full rings
Does it reverse the current?Yes, every half turnNo, never
Used ind.c. motora.c. generator
PurposeKeep it turning one wayLet the current alternate

A generator wants the alternating output, so it uses slip rings that never swap over. A motor wants steady rotation, so it needs the split ring.

Answering the exam question

If asked to explain the purpose of the split ring commutator, a full answer says all three of these:

  • It reverses the current in the coil every half turn.
  • It does this as the coil passes through the vertical, the dead spot.
  • So the turning effect always acts in the same direction, and the coil keeps rotating one way instead of rocking back and forth.
Not enough: saying only that it "reverses the current". You must say when and, crucially, what that achieves.